Features:

Share on:

Your guide to choosing the carat size for your engagement ring

Buying an engagement ring is a monumental decision, and one of the most pivotal aspects is determining the perfect carat size. While some might be drawn to the allure of larger diamonds, others may prioritise subtle elegance. Here’s an in-depth guide to help you choose the ideal carat size for your engagement ring.

 

Read summary

How do you choose the perfect carat size for your engagement ring?

When selecting an engagement ring's carat size, several key factors work together to create the ideal choice. While the average engagement ring in North America and Europe features a 1.0 to 1.2-carat diamond, personal preference should guide your decision. The diamond's appearance depends not just on carat weight, but also on cut quality, setting style, and the wearer's hand size. Smaller hands can make diamonds appear larger, while certain cuts like oval or marquise can create the illusion of greater size.

Budget naturally plays a role, with 1-carat diamonds typically ranging from €3,900 to €4,500, though exceptional stones can reach €12,000. Consider that settings like halos can enhance a smaller diamond's visual impact, while factors like cut quality and metal choice can significantly influence the ring's overall appearance. The key is finding the balance between size, quality, and personal style that best represents your relationship.

Read more below

Most viewed diamond jewels

.

woman's hand holding two diamond rings, each having a different carat weight

Understanding average carat weight

Curious about the typical carat weight for engagement rings? The term “carat” refers to the weight of a diamond, with one carat equaling 200 milligrams. While carat weight significantly influences the size and value of a diamond, it's important to note that bigger doesn’t always mean better. Factors such as cut, shape, and setting can make a diamond appear larger than its actual weight, showcasing expert craftsmanship.

In North America and Europe, most engagement rings feature diamonds weighing between 1.0 and 1.2 carats, offering a balance between size, visual impact, and affordability. However, trends vary worldwide, and preferences may lean toward smaller or larger diamonds depending on location and budget. To explore these trends further and discover what might be the right fit for you, check out our detailed article on average carat weight.

The importance of personal preference in finding the appropriate carat size

When it comes to choosing the appropriate carat size, personal preference reigns supreme. Some may dream of a dazzlingly large diamond that captures attention from across the room, while others might prefer a more understated, yet equally stunning, gem. The key is to consider what feels right for you and your partner. After all, this ring is a symbol of your unique relationship.

Budget considerations when deciding

While the price of a diamond is influenced by carat size, quality, and shape, finding a diamond that aligns with your personal preferences is often about making informed decisions rather than focusing solely on budget. For example, a 1.00-carat diamond can typically range between €3,900 and €4,500, while exceptional diamonds of the same weight may reach up to €12,000, depending on quality and market trends.

It's important to note that diamond shape also plays a crucial role in price variation. Round diamonds, known for their brilliance and popularity, tend to cost more than other shapes like cushion or princess cuts, even at the same carat weight. With BAUNAT’s range of options, you can tailor your choice to reflect your individual taste, opting for the diamond that resonates with both your style and expectations.

Hand and ring size

Interestingly, the size of the wearer’s hand and finger can influence how a diamond appears. Smaller hands can make a diamond look larger, while larger hands might make the same diamond seem smaller. Similarly, a slender ring band can accentuate the size of the diamond, creating a more prominent effect. It’s essential to try on a few rings to see how different carat sizes visually balance with your hand and finger dimensions. Find out more about measuring your partner’s finger size.

Optical illusions and perceived size: how the cut and setting play a significant role

Diamonds are masters of illusion. The way a diamond is cut can significantly affect its perceived size. For example, elongated shapes like oval, marquise, and pear cuts tend to appear larger than their actual carat weight. Additionally, a well-cut diamond with excellent symmetry and proportions will reflect light more efficiently, making it look more substantial and more brilliant.

The setting of a diamond also has a profound effect on how its size is perceived. Certain settings, such as halo settings, create an optical illusion that makes the centre diamond look larger by surrounding it with smaller diamonds. Similarly, bezel settings can give the impression of a larger stone by encasing the diamond in a thin metal rim. The choice of metal colour can also impact perception; for example, a white metal like platinum or white gold can enhance the brilliance and apparent size of a diamond.
alo setting white gold ring with 0.50 carat solitaire diamond and round brilliant diamonds

Pros and cons of different carat weights

Below 1 carat

If a 1.00ct diamond isn't your preferred choice, we recommend considering designs that enhance the diamond's visual impact, such as the halo or trilogy settings, which can make the overall appearance look more substantial. The halo design is an excellent choice if you prefer to maintain the classic single centre stone look, while enhancing its visual impact.Extra sparkle is added through a circle of smaller diamonds surrounding the centre stone, so even if the centre stone weighs just 0.50ct, the whole design will be just as stunning and brilliant.
elegant yellow gold engagement ring with three princess cut diamonds.
The trilogy design can be an original alternative as instead of it being one stone that weighs 1.00ct, you can have three smaller stones that total 1.00ct. Furthermore, the trilogy symbolises the past, present and future of your relationship which adds a romantic vibe to the design. Here are the pros and cons:

Pros:
  • More affordable
  • Often appear more delicate and graceful
  • Great for individuals with smaller hands or those who prefer subtlety
Cons:
  • May not have the same visual impact as larger stones
  • Fewer opportunities to showcase intricate settings

1 to 2 carats

Pros:
  • Strikes a balance between size and affordability
  • More noticeable yet still elegant
  • Offers a wide range of setting styles

Cons:
  • Can be pricier than smaller diamonds
  • May require a more robust setting for security

Above 2 carats

Pros:
  • Presents a striking and impressive appearance
  • Ideal for those who desire a statement piece
  • Allows for more creative and elaborate settings

Cons:
  • Significantly more expensive
  • Heavier and may feel bulkier on the finger
  • Requires more care to protect against damage

Looking at the other 3 C’s of diamonds: cut, clarity and colour
When determining how many carats your diamond engagement ring should be it is also important to consider the cut, clarity and colour of the diamond.
A smaller diamond with a better cut will sparkle beautifully and appear larger than it actually is. And that is not the only tip in having a diamond look bigger than it actually is. When choosing the right diamonds, consider the 4Cs: cut, colour, clarity, and carat. Together, these details are indispensable in your engagement ring quest.

Given the market is in a constant state of flux, there is no fixed price for a 1-carat diamond. This is why we adjust our prices at BAUNAT every week to reflect market dynamics, ensuring you always get the most fair price.
woman's hand holding snake skin purse, wearing rings with different precious metals and carat weights

What about the precious metal carats?

The value of the precious metal is also expressed in karats. So, you may also want to consider the karats of the precious metal in your engagement ring as well. While diamond carats indicate the weight of the stone per 0.2 grams, in precious metals, karats indicate the mixed-metal content in the alloy.

At BAUNAT, for an 18-karat gold ring we use 75% pure gold and 25% silver, copper or palladium. 18-karat gold is the optimum jewellery content. Less than 18 kt renders the ring pieces less valuable, but pure gold is very soft and fragile. So more than 18-carat gold will make your ring less robust and too delicate for long-term wear.

Find out more about the precious metals you can choose from here

Ready to determine your carat size?

Choosing the perfect carat size for your engagement ring involves a blend of personal preference, budget considerations, and understanding how different factors influence the diamond’s appearance. By taking the time to explore these elements, you can find a ring that not only dazzles but also resonates with your unique love story.

If you’re ready to take the next step, why not book a consultation with one of our expert jewellers at BAUNAT? Allow us to assist you in finding the perfect diamond that embodies your elegance and sophistication.

Happy diamond shopping!

Contact our diamond jewellery advisors

  • Stefaan Mouradian & Steven Boelens

  • Founders of BAUNAT

  • Stefaan Mouradian

    Stefaan is Co-Founder of BAUNAT, Managing Director and President of the Board. He combines two master’s degrees (Business Administration and Economics) with a broad knowledge of the global business world. Stefaan has held various management positions in the banking & finance industry and was also for many years strategic advisor in the international diamond and jewellery industry. As a real entrepreneur he is savvy in a large variety of domains like E-commerce, finance, legal, real estate, strategy, marketing, management, and of course diamonds.

    Steven Boelens

    Steven Boelens is the Co-Founder of BAUNAT and Executive Board Member. His extensive experience as a diamond broker, marketing manager and co-founder of multiple companies make him a true master when it comes to diamonds and diamond jewellery. In addition to his experience, Steven is a HRD graduate in polished and rough diamonds which he completed in Antwerp. He got to know the fundamentals of business at the Vlerick Business School and at Ghent University where he got his master’s degrees.

Stefaan Mouradian

Stefaan is Co-Founder of BAUNAT, Managing Director and President of the Board. He combines two master’s degrees (Business Administration and Economics) with a broad knowledge of the global business world. Stefaan has held various management positions in the banking & finance industry and was also for many years strategic advisor in the international diamond and jewellery industry. As a real entrepreneur he is savvy in a large variety of domains like E-commerce, finance, legal, real estate, strategy, marketing, management, and of course diamonds.

Steven Boelens

Steven Boelens is the Co-Founder of BAUNAT and Executive Board Member. His extensive experience as a diamond broker, marketing manager and co-founder of multiple companies make him a true master when it comes to diamonds and diamond jewellery. In addition to his experience, Steven is a HRD graduate in polished and rough diamonds which he completed in Antwerp. He got to know the fundamentals of business at the Vlerick Business School and at Ghent University where he got his master’s degrees.